Testimonials
Victoria and David Reische
Dec 2025
Cheryl and Pauline are the best agents we have worked with in almost 45 years of dealing in real estate. Incredible work ethic and dedication. Great people and would recommend them to anyone who is looking to buy or sell property.
Steve & Amy Houmes
Dec 2025
We consider ourselves lucky that we had Cheryl as our real estate agent. She is knowledgeable, professional, really listens to what you are looking for, and makes what can be a very stressful process smooth and seamless. This is the third transaction we have done with Cheryl and in each of them we always knew she had our backs. The way she handles each client is with the geniune desire to see them in the ideal home for them. Her approach makes a sometimes nerve wracking process, dare I say fun, and has earned her many long term friendships. I cannot say enough about her as a partner in the real estate process - she is a good human being too which shines through in everything she does.
Nicki McMahan
Dec 2025
Can't recommend Cheryl highly enough and have given her name to many friends. Now that her sister Pauline Simon has joined the team their commitment to always go above and beyond has only doubled. Cheryl has helped us buy and sell several properties over the years and working with her has always been a joy! We can't thank her enough for her great kindness and attention to detail. She's the best.
Bill & Kathy Beck
Dec 2025
We were so fortunate to have Cheryl Mauer as our real estate agent. Every turn in the road, through the whole process, she was there for us. She was knowledgeable, professional and yet very personable, helpful and kind . We would recommend Cheryl to anyone looking to sell their house. She was simply great!
Bill and Kathy Beck
Barbara Von Tobel
Dec 2025
I really enjoyed working with Cheryl and her sister Pauline. Their confidence and expertise took my anxiety down quite a few notches. They always showed up with a cheerful attitude and many solutions to problems big and small. I always recommend Cheryl and Pauline to friends.
Laurie Mayers
Dec 2025
I really appreciated Cheryl and Pauline's responsiveness and support throughout the home searching and buying process. Their local knowledge and knowledge of the current market was also critical to the success of my transaction.
Eileen Bergevin
Dec 2025
Cheryl and Pauline were professional, responsive, and always ready to assist in any way to help sell our home. We enjoyed working with them personally and appreciated the calm demeanor that both exhibited. They work as a team with a "can do" attitude. Their expert advice on real estate was given, but ultimately they always acknowledged that it was our home and gave us final decision making, which we appreciated. We would highly recommend Cheryl and Pauline to anyone looking to sell on the Island. They were a pleasure to work with.
Jesse and Eileen
Lance Odermat
Dec 2025
Cheryl Mauer was outstanding and the best agent we have dealt with anywhere
Dolores McCann
Dec 2025
My family has had 5 transactions with Cheryl. Each one was as smooth as can be. She is as professional as they come. I hope I don't need another transaction, bit if I do, I would choose Cheryl.
Bill McCann
Dec 2025
Cheryl is a real pro, outstanding in every way. Her expertise and marketing and negotiating skills were put together together us a full price offer in lass than 10 days, saving us additional expense for our bridge loan. We are very happy with our new home and many thanks to Cheryl and her sister Pauline for their help.
Mike Sekits
Dec 2025
Cheryl is experienced and responsive. She knows the local market well and how to negotiate best to achieve our objectives. I was very pleased with the process and the outcome. Cheryl should be on your shortlist when considering retaining a Realtor.
Tanya Yurovsky
Dec 2025
Cheryl Mauer was very attentive to our needs and interests and she helped us tremendously with her superb knowledge of the community and the local real estate market. Cheryl is an amazingly good listener, the skill that resulted in us purchasing just the right property that suits our needs. All communications and support from Cheryl were very professional and timely. We cannot say enough about Cheryl's responsiveness and negotiation skills. We would recommend Cheryl Mauer to anyone interested in selling or buying a property on Bainbridge. She is a real treasure. Thank you, Cheryl!
Roeliena Vanzanten
Dec 2025
Cheryl combines the very best of personal warmth , attentiveness and caring combined with professional knowledge of local culture and real estate, aiming to find the right match for her clients. We especially appreciate her patience while we were trying to figure out what our next steps had to be as an older couple ready to significantly downsize from a home into a small apartment. We highly recommend her!
Arnold Stern
Dec 2025
We are an older couple going through major downsizing from a house to a suitable apartment, returning to the island after five years. With a great deal of patience,, understanding, and attentiveness she helped us find the best living situation. It took quite some time, and we changed our perspective on next steps a couple of time and she supported us through that process. As a native islander who has been in real estate for several years she has a really good understanding of the different neighborhoods and sub cultures on the island. We had to communicate mostly from the east coast via phone and video, all of which worked out very well.
Cheryl is among the best of realtors we ever dealt with and we would come back to her and the agency may we need to make another move.
Ginger Newlin
Dec 2025
Cheryl Mauer ,is an exceptional example of professional , efficient , and politeness the quality we expected from Windermere real-estate broker ! She was always available for questions or help with the technical side of our experience ! My husband and I would gladly recommend her to friends and family . Sincerely , Ed and Ginger Newlin
William McCann
Dec 2025
Cheryl is top tier, a knowledgeable and personable professional who makes the process go smoothly from start to finish.
Evan Brown & Sarah Sinclair
Dec 2025
Cheryl was fantastic and really helped us navigate the market on Bainbridge Island. Would certainly recommend to anyone looking on the Island.
Brian Carney
Dec 2025
Cheryl is an amazing woman, not to mention the best realtor EVER. Seriously. We've been through this process a few times and usually the realtor, like a bad boyfriend, wines and dines you, and once you sign the exclusive listing, they are MIA. Not with Cheryl. She was there for every question, every concern, and was extremely respectful of our desires. That only makes sense, given she was our realtor, but you'd be surprised how often realtors forget or don't care who they owe their duty of loyalty too. The 4/5 stars for negotiation is only because who doesn't want to get more money? In reality, Cheryl sold our home in a few days for cash at the full listing price. It's unrealistic on our part to have expected more.
Diane Sawyer
Dec 2025
Would not dream of going with anyone else.
Cheryl is an all around professional and was always there when I needed anything. She became what I hope will be as much a friend as a realtor.
Bill McCann
Dec 2025
We were very happy with Cheryl on our ew hom purchase. Her knowledge of the market and negotiation skills with the builder saved us money.
Joe Salter
Dec 2025
Cheryl did a terrific job in every aspect of helping me sell my condo and buy a new one. And besides being a consummate professional, she’s a great person.
Joe Salter
Dec 2025
Cheryl did a terrific job on my condo sale and purchase. She’s a consummate professional.
Joe Salter
Dec 2025
Cheryl did a terrific job.
Steve Delmore
Dec 2025
Cheryl did an outstanding job for us.
Joan Holliday
Dec 2025
Cheryl is amazing. Our cross country move was made much easier knowing that she was on the other side helping us find our new home. We highly recommend Cheryl Mauer!
panda98110
Dec 2025
Cheryl is absolutely fabulous to work with! She helped us sell in a really tough market, as well as buying the home of our dreams (and this was no easy feat on many levels). She responds quickly, she's very knowledgable of the area and is upfront with you on all levels. We hope to work with Cheryl in the future!
debdowdney
Dec 2025
Cheryl won us more than I imagined was possible in the sale of my home. She is extremely focused on details and service. My family is set and able to move on because of her strategic planning and support. I highly recommend Cheryl. - She will be my RE agent going forward!
zuser20190212130527000
Dec 2025
Cheryl lover her work and clients, and it shows! As a first time home buyer, having her on my team was invaluable in navigating the complexities of the process. Besides being a joy to work with, Cheryl is an expert in her field and saved me from a potentially dangerous purchase thanks to her knowledge of the process and commitment to ensuring my best outcome! I trusted Cheryl every step of the way. Lastly, Cheryl is a pillar of the Bainbridge community - she knows everyone! Which made the whole process not only effective, but enjoyable! If you're looking for an agent - you've found yours!
Curtcarlisle
Dec 2025
Cheryl was an absolute pleasure to work with on our recent purchase of a condo on Bainbridge Island. Cheryl had very specific knowledge of the recent sales on the island and helped us negotiate a very fair price for our purchase. Cheryl is very good at what she does and we would definitely use her on our next purchase or sale of a home.
user19882018
Dec 2025
Cheryl was confident and professional from start to finish. She expertly managed our unique home's appeal to a wide market and was constantly available by phone to answer questions. She was a pleasure to work with and we would recommend her to anyone looking to buy or sell their home.